Well, I told friends of mine, you been tellin' lies 
How I was wrapped up in you 
But surprise, surprise 
Surprise, surprise 
I never wanted you that bad 
'Cause I knew you was tellin' lies 
Knew you was tellin' lies 
I could see it in your eyes 

Why did you hafta go and fool after 
We had got along just fine 
But surprise, surprise 
Surprise, surprise 
Fate is never strange to me 
I knew you was tellin' lies 
Knew you was tellin' lies 
I could see it in your eyes 

I knew you was tellin' lies 
Knew you was tellin' lies 
I could see it in your eyes 

I hope you're proud of all your chasin' 'round 
Thinkin' I was alone all night 
But surprise, surprise 
Surprise, surprise 
You're only foolin' yourself 
'Cause I knew you was tellin' lies 
Knew you was tellin' lies 
I could see it in your eyes 

Why did you hafta go and fool around 
After we got along so fine 
I knew you was tellin' lies 
We got along so fine 
But I knew you was tellin' lies 
Knew you was talkin' jive 
I could see it in your eyes